Are Leather Dog Collars Better Than Fabric?

If you’re trying to choose between a leather or fabric dog collar, you’re not alone—it’s one of the most common collar decisions dog owners make. fabric collars often seem like the easy option—colourful, lightweight, and cheap, while leather ones feel more traditional or high-end. But the real question is: which one’s actually better for your dog and your lifestyle?

What are the key differences between leather and fabric dog collars?

Leather and fabric collars aren’t just about looks—they’re made for different needs. Fabric dog collars (like nylon or polyester) are usually lightweight, come in loads of patterns, and tend to be quite cheap. But they also wear out more quickly, especially if your dog’s collar gets wet or dirty often.

Leather collars, like the ones in our leather dog collar collection, are made from natural materials that tend to age better over time. When cared for properly, they can last for years—often looking even better with age.

How a leather dog collar from Petiquette is made

If you’re the sort of person who’s tired of replacing fraying fabric collars or snapping buckles, switching to leather can be a game-changer. And if you’re unsure how long leather collars actually last, this post on how long do leather dog collars last might help put your mind at ease.

Which material is more comfortable for dogs?

Comfort is a biggie, especially for dogs who wear their collars all day. While fabric collars can be soft at first, they can also cause rubbing over time—particularly if they stay damp after walks or your dog has a sensitive neck.

A good quality leather collar, especially one with a soft lining like the ones we make, naturally moulds to your dog’s neck. It warms with their body and moves with them. If comfort’s your priority, you might also want to look at which collar is most comfortable for dogs to get more tips on what to look for.

A Staffordshire bull terrier lying on the decking wearing an orange leather collar from Petiquette

And for breeds with curly coats or longer fur, a rolled leather collar can be a clever choice—it helps prevent matting and keeps the fur from flattening. You may want to read our useful post Why Use A Rolled Leather Collar? if you are considering this style for your dog.

Is leather really more durable than fabric?

In short, yes—especially when we’re talking about quality leather. While fabric collars can stretch, stain, or even snap over time, a leather collar holds its shape and strength. It’s one of the reasons many dog trainers and long-time dog owners swear by leather.

If durability is what you’re after, leather wins hands down—but it does need a little care to keep it in good shape. If you’ve not owned one before, here’s a guide on how to clean and care for a leather dog collar so you know what’s involved.

What about puppies—can they wear leather collars?

Absolutely. A lot of people assume puppies need soft fabric collars, but that’s not necessarily true. As long as the collar is lightweight and well-fitted, leather can actually be a brilliant choice. It avoids the rough edges and bulk that some cheaper fabric collars have.

A young red puppy proudly wearing a lime green leather puppy collar from Petiquette

We make leather puppy collars that are soft, lightweight, and designed to grow with your pup. If you’re unsure whether it’s too early for leather, have a read through can puppies wear leather collars—it’s got some helpful info for new owners.

What kind of collar suits your lifestyle?

If your dog spends lots of time swimming or hiking in all weather, a quick-drying waterproof collar might make sense—but even then, not all fabric collars hold up well over time. You might find yourself constantly replacing them as they start to smell or look worn.

For most everyday walks, lounging around at home, and everything in between, leather is a reliable, stylish, and long-lasting choice. And if you like accessories with a bit of character, there are designs that blend durability with personality — like our Skull Studded Leather Dog Collar, handmade in soft Italian leather and built to last through daily wear.

If you’re someone who enjoys choosing accessories that last, the upgrade is well worth it.

So, Are Leather Collars the Better Choice?

So, are leather dog collars better than fabric? If you’re looking for something comfortable, durable, and beautiful, leather wins in most cases. It’s not about being fancy—it’s about investing in something that looks good, feels good for your dog, and lasts longer than a few soggy walks.

a black spaniel wearing yellow leather dog collar handmade by petiquette

Ready to treat your dog to a new leather collar? Explore our full collection of handmade leather dog collars.

Looking for more advice on choosing the right leather collar?

Here are some helpful reads from the rest of our leather collar blog series:

Read next:

FAQs

Is leather or fabric better for dogs with allergies?

Leather is less likely to irritate skin, especially when it’s vegetable-tanned and lined with soft leather, like ours. Fabric collars can sometimes trap allergens like pollen or mould.

Do leather dog collars hold smells more than fabric ones?

Actually, no. Fabric tends to hold smells more readily—especially if it gets wet often. Leather, when cared for properly, is easier to wipe clean and deodorise.

Are leather collars heavier than fabric collars?

They can be, but the difference is usually minimal—especially if the collar is designed with a lighter buckle and a tapered shape. Most dogs don’t notice the difference.

Can you get leather collars in fun colours like fabric ones?

You can with Petiquette Collars. We use Italian leather in over 28 colours, so you can still go bold while enjoying the durability of leather.

Are leather collars worth the price?

Yes—if you’re looking for something long-lasting. While leather collars might cost more upfront, you’ll replace them far less often than cheaper fabric alternatives.